Jan Frodeno vs ‘cyborg’ Norwegians, who would win? Macca on ‘Frodo’ return

Macca with the lowdown on Jan ahead of a huge 2023

News Director
Last updated -
T100 Triathlon World Tour
Redefining triathlon

Jan Frodeno has committed to the IRONMAN World Championship this year, despite the fact it’s in Nice for the first time rather than his beloved Kona.

Triathlon legend Chris McCormack won twice in Hawaii, mopped up multiple other titles around the world, remains ground-breaking in all spheres of the sport and knows Frodeno well. That all puts him in the perfect position to weigh up the challenges ahead for the brilliant German as he enters what he has called his “last year of full professional racing”.

Frodeno’s 2019 Kona win a class apart

We’ll hear more about Macca’s thoughts on that Nice / Kona dynamic over the next week or two and while it’s virtually certain Frodeno’s rivals this September will not include the last two winners of the IMWC – Norwegian duo Gustav Iden and Kristian Blummenfelt – it’s clear that he feels many people are perhaps too hasty to hail a changing of the guard.

In a wide-ranging interview, where typically he does not pull any punches, the Aussie told TRI247: “At the end of the day, Jan Frodeno’s 2019 Kona is the best performance in Kona I’ve ever seen in my life. And you’re talking to a guy who has watched that race since 1984.

IRONMAN World Championship
Frodeno’s Kona win in 2019 [Photo by Tom Pennington/Getty Images for IRONMAN]

“There have been some white-hot performances. Luc Van Lierde put one in years ago. No question that Gustav Iden’s performance last year was cracking, off of that big bike time.

“Jan’s pulled off massive performances to win World Championships and at the Olympics to win his gold medal. Gustav’s performance in Kona was very, very good, but Jan’s is the best I’ve seen done in Kona – and he did it in flat shoes, none of the trendy carbon shoes you have now.”


Frodeno vs the Norwegians, who wins?

That does raise the obvious question, who would he back if Frodeno and the Norwegians were ever to lock horns when all parties are fit and in form?

Chris McCormack 2023 photo credit Daniel Vazquez
McCormack says we’re very “fortunate” in this current era [Photo credit: Mana Group]

“I don’t know how it ends up, but it wouldn’t be a walk in the park for the Norwegians. One thing that p***** me off about triathlon is how short people’s memories are of how good people are, you know?

“Of course, technology and equipment are gonna change the game and change the pace, and even the swim and run courses in Kona have changed now. But we’re still comparing performances over different courses with athletes of the past. That’s so unfair.

“We’re still stuck in the Dave Scott and Mark Allen days. Those two are remarkable pioneers of this sport. But what we’re seeing now and in the last generations is depth and the athletes actually racing the distance.


‘Why compare? Just enjoy’

“Look at the palmares of this current crop of athletes. Look at their consistency. We’re talking about the Norwegians and we’re talking Jan Frodeno, we’re talking about Alistair Brownlee because of what they’ve pulled off consistently, not one-off performances.

Jan Frodeno’s the best to do it. Kristian and Gustav are on the way to trying to dismantle that, which is what every next generation should be doing. Alistair retired Jan from short-course racing. So we’re lucky as fans of the sport to be able to sit back and watch that. Why compare? Just enjoy and understand that we are very, very fortunate.

“What we see nowadays is a lot more real-time technology feeding these athletes with information, so you don’t see the blow-ups. It reduces the spontaneity of racing, it’s very robotic and cyborg and that suits that Norwegian way. Jan can play both ways. So I think in a match race, I think Jan’s spontaneity and his ability to race from the head, not always from the numbers, would give him the upper hand if they were all in perfect condition.

“He’s a very, very difficult man to beat.”

Jonathan Turner
Written by
Jonathan Turner
Jonathan Turner is News Director for both TRI247 and RUN247, and is accustomed to big-name interviews, breaking news stories and providing unrivalled coverage for endurance sports.  
Discover more
Kate Auld riding on an indoor trainer
Rouvy vs Zwift: our indoor cyclists put them to the test
Triathlete riding a time trial bike wearing a Ryzon tri suit
Tri suit buying guide: how to find your perfect tri suit
Cameron Brown signs off with seventh in his 25th and final appearance at IRONMAN New Zealand photo credit Graeme Murray
What is an average & good time for a triathlon?
Professional triathletes on the bike course at Challenge Almere-Amsterdam
Fastest triathlon courses: Best IRONMAN, long course and middle distance races for a sure-fire personal best
PTO European Open 2023 Ibiza - Ashleigh Gentle
Ashleigh Gentle on T100 racing: ‘The best battles are yet to come’
latest News
Magnus Ditlev en route to another famous win at Challenge Roth 2023
Magnus Ditlev talks triathlon legends, T100 Tour calendar and who he can’t wait to race in 2024
Ben Kanute Escape from Alcatraz 2021
Latest T100 Triathlon World Tour stop announced after PTO unveil iconic location for California race
Mike Phillips IRONMAN New Zealand champion 2023 photo credit Graeme Murray
International stars announced for 40th anniversary of IRONMAN New Zealand
Challenge Kaiserwinkl-Walchsee 2023 - Photo Credit José Luis Hourcade / Challenge Walchsee 2023
German rising star looking to finally crack PTO podium at 2024 T100 Triathlon World Tour
Kenji Nener at the 2023 Asian Games.
The Norwegian Method: Kenji Nener reveals what it’s like to train with Blummenfelt and Iden
Story to tell?
Share interesting & inspirational stories with our news team
The SBRX Group

Proudly elevating endurance sports through content, products & services

Share to...