The Collins Cup 2020 – an early look at the potential teams
As I’m sure you’ve seen, either on TRI247 (HERE) or elsewhere, the ‘Ryder Cup of Triathlon’, the Collins Cup (www.thecollinscup.com) was announced this week.
The first major project from the many years of behind-the-scenes efforts of those involved in the Professional Triathletes Organisation (www.protriathletes.org), after a few false starts and delays, will debut at the end of May in Samorin, Slovakia. The ‘$2million prize purse’ tag – more than three times the Kona total – certainly grabbed some headlines. More on that below.
Who gets to race?
36 athletes – 18 men, 18 women – will get to race in the Collins Cup, representing three teams:
Thus, each team will comprise of 6 men and 6 women, racing over the middle distance, in a series of 12 matches.
How you get selected is via two routes:
- The top four athletes (male and female) selected** will be the top four ranked athletes within their respective teams – as at 4th May 2020 – based upon the PTO World Rankings™
- The final two athletes (male and female), are designated as “Captains’ Picks” and “will be selected by a committee of non-athlete members of the PTO Board, in consultation with the Team Captains”
(** it is possible that a ‘selected’ athlete might not accept that place – injury, illness, other commitments (e.g. ITU season), and thus I would expect in such an instance that the auto-qualifier position will roll down to the next available athlete in the rankings).
In summary, it’s a process that is along similar lines to the Ryder Cup and provides a route to qualification through performance (via the rankings), but also offers flexibility / opportunity for a ‘wild card’ selection too.
For example, if a quality athlete is relatively low in the rankings because injury has prevented them racing, but is back to form by selection date – or you have a World Champion like Gustav Iden who has only raced over the 70.3 distance twice in the last two seasons.
Personally, I would like to see the “Captains’ Picks” truly being just that, eliminating the ‘committee’ reference and involvement. That would enhance the scrutiny, speculation and ultimately judgement as to whether they have chosen well, putting additional responsibility on the Captains’ position. If you are familiar with the Ryder Cup, you’ll be familiar with the (heated) discussions around this very point – and ongoing interest leading up to, during and post-event will be crucial to success.
(Big) Money… who’ll get it?
The biggest talking point – and ‘issue’ for many – is the $2million prize purse. Or more specifically, it’s allocation.
Firstly, it’s worth noting a couple of things to give some (relative) context versus the history of our sport:
- $2million is, by far, the biggest total amount that has been on offer at a triathlon event.
- The $125k that will be collected by the highest ranked male and female athletes racing at the Collins Cup, is more than the first prize at the IRONMAN World Championship ($120k).
- The lowest ranked male and female athletes racing will receive $20,000 – that is the same amount as the second-placed finisher at the IRONMAN 70.3 World Championship.
Sounds good, and with the difficulty that most Pro triathletes have with maintaining a sustainable career, in aggregate at least it is certainly a massive step forward. What does stand out though, is that the allocation of the prize money is not based upon either the result of that athlete at the event (either within their ‘match’ or indeed, relative to other matches), or even the overall success of their team.
The top-ranked athletes get the big(ger) bucks, with the full breakdown being based upon the PTO World Rankings™ ahead of the event in what is effectively appearance fee format:
Of course, that raises some obvious questions – to which the PTO’s response is provided in their FAQs on the Collins Cup website.
It needs to matter…
Whatever the prize money is and whatever method is used to allocate and award it (now, and in future years, since as a members organisation the athletes will have an opportunity to change things over time), the viewers belief and trust that the event truly matters to the athletes taking part is, in my opinion, perhaps the biggest key to its success.
The passion of both the players and supporters at the Ryder Cup is intense; making the team is truly an honour, being overlooked for selection is devastating and typically, a losing Captain will be critiqued and questioned, while poor performance from a player will be analysed in depth.
For the Collins Cup to work, WE NEED THAT PASSION FROM EVERYONE INVOLVED.
Many would argue that it took until the winning putt from Sam Torrance in 1985 to win the cup for Europe, that the Ryder Cup truly gained it current status and importance. We can’t wait the best part of 60 years to reach that point, but equally, making it ‘matter’ from a standing start isn’t easy either.
To quote Boxing promoter, Eddie Hearn: “No passion, no point”.
So, who’ll be racing?
Ok, so what follows is an outline of what the 2020 Collins Cup teams would be, if they were selected now – but with some key assumptions:
- All of the auto-qualified athletes were available, not injured and accepted their selection
- Because two of the places (male and female) in each team are “Captains’ Picks” – for the purposes of this review only – I am going to assume that the Captains’ in each case, chose to select the next ranked athletes available (5th and 6th). (As the season progresses and the selection deadline approaches, we’ll start to look in more depth at who could be in the running for those Captains’ Picks).
And with those assumptions, these are what the teams would look like now. (The PTO World Rankings will of course start to change, with IRONMAN 70.3 South Africa the first points scoring event of 2020, coming up this weekend).
Collins Cup Teams, Pro Women – ‘As at 1st January 2020’
|Race Ranking||Actual PTO Ranking||Purse||Team Position||Athlete|
|1||1||$125,000||Europe 1||Daniela Ryf|
|2||2||$115,000||Europe 2||Lucy Charles-Barclay|
|3||3||$105,000||Internationals 1||Sarah Crowley|
|4||4||$95,000||Europe 3||Anne Haug|
|5||5||$85,000||Europe 4||Holly Lawrence|
|6||6||$75,000||Internationals 2||Carrie Lester|
|7||7||$65,000||Internationals 3||Teresa Adam|
|8||8||$55,000||USA 1||Heather Jackson|
|9||9||$50,000||Europe 5 (CP)||Laura Philipp|
|10||10||$40,000||USA 2||Skye Moench|
|11||11||$35,000||USA 3||Chelsea Sodaro|
|12||12||$30,000||USA 4||Sarah Piampiano|
|13||13||$25,000||Europe 6 (CP)||Daniela Bleymehl|
|14||15||$24,000||Internationals 4||Paula Findlay|
|15||16||$23,000||USA 5 (CP)||Jocelyn McCauley|
|16||17||$22,000||Internationals 5 (CP)||Ellie Salthouse|
|17||19||$21,000||Internationals 6 (CP)||Amelia Watkinson|
|18||20||$20,000||USA 6 (CP)||Jacalyn Hering|
Total prize money, by team (WOMEN):
- Europe – $495,000
- Internationals – £312,000
- USA – $203,000
Collins Cup Teams, Pro Men – ‘As at 1st January 2020′
|Race Ranking||Actual PTO Ranking||Purse||Team Position||Athlete|
|1||1||$125,000||Europe 1||Jan Frodeno|
|2||2||$115,000||Europe 2||Alistair Brownlee|
|3||3||$105,000||Europe 3||Sebastian Kienle|
|4||4||$95,000||Internationals 1||Lionel Sanders|
|5||5||$85,000||USA 1||Ben Hoffman|
|6||6||$75,000||USA 2||Rodolphe Von Berg|
|7||7||$65,000||Internationals 2||Cameron Wurf|
|8||8||$55,000||Internationals 3||Braden Currie|
|9||9||$50,000||Europe 4||Javier Gomez|
|10||10||$40,000||USA 3||Timothy O'Donnell|
|11||11||$35,000||Europe 5 (CP)||Michael Weiss|
|12||12||$30,000||Europe 6 (CP)||Joe Skipper|
|13||13||$25,000||Internationals 4||Tyler Butterfield|
|14||18||$24,000||Internationals 5 (CP)||Sam Appleton|
|15||19||$23,000||USA 4||Matt Hanson|
|16||21||$22,000||Internationals 6 (CP)||Cody Beals|
|17||24||$21,000||USA 5 (CP)||Andrew Starykowicz|
|18||27||$20,000||USA 6 (CP)||Matthew Russell|
Total prize money, by team (MEN):
- Europe – $460,000
- Internationals – £286,000
- USA – $264,000
Team Europe would have to be considered the strong favourites, with the athletes selected and their ranking reflected in the overall percentage of the prize pot that would potentially come to them in aggregate.
An alternative view, might be to say – given the above teams and the assumptions given – what is the ‘average PTO World Ranking by team’:
However you look at, Europe would have to be the early and strong favourites to raise the first Collins Cup.